New? Free Sign Up
Then check our Welcome Center to a Community Caring about Sleep Apnea diagnosis and Sleep Apnea treatment:
CPAP machines, Sleep Apnea surgery and dental appliances.
Tags:
Give us some specifics: Mask? Machine settings? Sleep position(s)? Humidifier setting? Had acid reflux before CPAP? Head of bed elevated? Time between dinner and lying down? History of allergies/nasal congestion?
Rock Hinkle said:The term "positional apnea" still makes me giggle. In 99.9% of the apneac cases I have seen events have been worse in the supine position. This is the normal nature of apnea due to gravity and muscle atonia being the biggest culprit. I could see coming up with a name for apnea being worse in the lateral position. This would truly be "positional apnea". Supine apnea is just apnea.
If I remember correctly from earlier threads, you have not read any of the literature on Positional Sleep Apnea (PSA). You then may be interested to read the most often referred to medical study on PSA which is one published in Chest Journal, October 2005, http://chestjournal.chestpubs.org/content/128/4/2130.long.
In this study, the authors discuss previous studies of PSA and write, "Prior studies have classified positional sleep apnea as an AHI in the supine posture that was twice that in the nonsupine posture. Using this definition, approximately 50 to 60% of patients with sleep apnea were classified as positional. When we utilized this definition, 143 of 248 evaluable patients (57.7%; 95% CI, 51.5 to 63.8%) met the definition for positional sleep apnea, ".
So using the most common definition of PSA, it has been found that roughly 50 - 60% of patients meet the criteria. That would mean that 40% or more do not meet the definition.
If you read the Chest Journal study, you will see that the authors propose a more strict definition for PSA in which many fewer patients meet the criteria and many more patients would be considered to have non-positional sleep apnea.
One big disappointment that I have personally experienced with two certified sleep labs and several sleep doctors, is the total lack of consideration of whether the patient has PSA, whether the patient could be treated with positional therapy alone, and whether patients with titrated pressures above 10 could be treated with lower pressures in conjunction with positional therapy. In discussion with hundreds of patients, it has been very rare to find ones who know whether they have PSA and what the implications for treatment are. The professional field has a long way to go.
© 2025 Created by The SleepGuide Crew.
Powered by