SleepGuide

Sleep Apnea Forum Bringing Power to the Patient

Sleep Apnea Depression. If you're asking which one it is, sleep apnea or depression, you're in good company: unfortunately, primary care physicians, psychiatrists, psychologists and patients often confuse sleep apnea and depression. Understandably so. Loss of energy, loss of interest in once enjoyable things, difficulty concentrating and fatigue are common symptoms of depression. But they are also common symptoms of sleep apnea, and new research is continually emerging to show the connection between the two. An article published in the September 2005 issue of the journal Chest concluded that many patients with depression symptoms improved markedly when treated with CPAP. The study showed that of those being treated with CPAP, 40 of the 41 participants taking antidepressants and those not taking them showed decreases in their depression scores.

But if you're relying solely on the opinion of your psychiatrist to treat your depression, a referral to a sleep physician is not likely. Why? Pharmaceutical companies spend tens of millions of dollars in advertising each year to convince psychiatrists and the general public that antidepressants are the way to treat depression. What about when antidepressants don't work? MORE antidepressants! The pharmaceuticals have created a new category of antidepressants which they call "Add-On" antidepressants. By its own admission, one pharmaceutical company that puts out the "Add-On" medication Abilify (aripiprazole) acknowledges that "studies show that approximately two-thirds of those diagnosed with depression did not achieve adequate symptom relief after taking an antidepressant alone."

The bottom line is that if you suffer from depression, and have one or more of the signs of sleep apnea, such as snoring, you'd do yourself a favor by getting evaluated by a sleep physician and not just a psychiatrist. I can tell you from personal experience that this is a good idea. I did it and it changed my life.

Tags: antidepressant, apnea, apnia, cpap, depression, medication, sleep

Comment

You need to be a member of SleepGuide to add comments!

Join SleepGuide

99 Comment by 99 on January 29, 2010 at 2:42am
there is reactive depression
and organic depression

reactive depession is your depressed because of the circumstances you find youself in
organic depression is a mental imbalance of brain chemistry
Stacy M. Portillo Comment by Stacy M. Portillo on August 8, 2009 at 11:58am
I was recently diagnosed with sleep apnea - 3 months ago when I had my 3rd child in the hospital. I have always "burned the candle at both ends" but looking back, I have been diagnosed with depression, GAD (General Anxiety Disorder), didn't want to be active or do things socially so much with my husband after our first child (our 7 1/2 yr old) was born, was always "tired", anxious, stressed, depressed at times, tend to obsess about things and have LOTS of trouble focusing and being as productive as i KNOW i can be... tonite is my 2nd sleep study with the CPAP... I'm praying that I'm right and that (now that I know about the apnea) it is all connected and that i'll be a NEW person!
Brennan William Bilbao Crawford Comment by Brennan William Bilbao Crawford on August 5, 2009 at 7:47am
Sleep apnea doesn't sound as bad as it really is. Depression sounds a lot worse since it's a mental chemical imbalance. However, sleep apnea in my opinion is MUCH worse if not treated because it gives you so many problems, such as depression possibly being one of them. Now here's my story. He summer before my freshman year in high school I woke up one morning and decided I felt kind of funny, not too sure what I felt like, maybe a bit tired, but for sure never felt like it before.. I remember going outside to my pool and jumping in it expecting that the pools cool water would wake me up.. But sadly it never did and In fact since that day I never felt the same. Leading to me feeling very depresses, low self esteem, low energy, groggy, everything seemed pointless, my days literally turned into living hell no exaggeration, my mind was altered (imagine getting really drunk and compare that state of mind to your normal sober state, that was how much of a difference i felt by saying my mind was altered, that was the worst part too, because I didn't know anything about altered minds because I've never drinkin or anything before that. My parents always told me that it was my fault for complaining too much or not getting enough sleep. Once I conquered gettting enough sleep they blamed me for they put the blame on me not going to bed at the right time. They didn't react to how I felt until it started affecting how they felt, when I was so lost in this world and hated myself along with everyone else I made the worst choices by stealing alcohol and plenty of other bad routines. The therapist and pychologist they got for me didn't do anything to help me, one told me to think about what I do before I do it, the other diagnosed me with depression and put me on sonata I think that's what it was called, the pills didn't work and for about a two year period I was on cycle of taking these pills and switching them every few months. Around the time I was nearly sent away, I had a sleep study and was told I wake up from sleep apnea 8 times every 2 minutes. He said I wasn't getting any deep sleep and it was growing everything off with me. this led to me eventually getting surgery getting rid of my tonsils it corrected the problem halfway, and then was given the machine to cometely fix the problem. Now I am using the machine on and off, have seen some improvement with myself. Was wondering who else out there felt this same altered mind view on life as I did? Also how many times do you have to wear the machine for you to start really noticing a difference in the well being and way you feel? Thanks and best wishes to everyone going through such hard times!
Michelle Sanders Comment by Michelle Sanders on July 23, 2009 at 10:16pm
My psychiatrist was the one that referred me to have a sleep study. I've been taking antidepressants since I was 16. It wasn't until I moved 2 years ago that I found a really good psychiatrist. I went in one day so sleepy I nearly dozed off in his office! I told him I was really tired ALL the time. I didn't feel depressed, just tired. There are really good "shrinks" out there...but they are just not educated enough about sleep apnea.
sandman Comment by sandman on June 16, 2009 at 1:57am
After having read the blogs above, I have to realize that I'm in the thick of it, sleep apnea, at the moment, I have all of the symptoms including depression, anxiety and dreams of drowning. I have been here before, six years ago, have had two surgeries which provided some relief and have been unable to use a CPAP. My anxious thoughts about my life work and the failure of a practice that I love, have only exacerbated my health issues. I live alone and am proceeding cautiously with my medical choices. Jaw surgery seems more of a risk than a sollution, but I feel like I am running out of options. Anti-depressants have not worked. I have my fifth sleep study this week and hope to determine a least a path to some relief. Does anyone have advice as to how to get started on a CPAP without waking by suffocation. I just can't breath against the pressure, no matter how low the setting.
sheila Mannix Comment by sheila Mannix on May 30, 2009 at 5:27pm
Bless your husband, you are so very fortunate to have a husband to stand behind you in all of this. I lost the love of my life because of all of this, we were together for 25 years, so this adds to the anxiety, and little sleep for 45 years. Yep, I also cannot process so many daily living things because of the long term sleep deprivation. I struggle to learn new things, read the news, creativity, driving, speaking with clarity. It is suffocating me as well throughout every day. I do so understand. I had a sleep study several years ago and was only a 6 out of 10 level, but I know in reality I am much more than that as I identify with all you say. I go in for another study in a week. This anxiety and depression for years is taking its toll in every way, but I do know it is from lack of sleep since age 12, when we all need it the most. Thanks for sharing.
Jeannie Christmas Smith Comment by Jeannie Christmas Smith on May 28, 2009 at 12:07am
All these stories are very encouraging and give much comfort to me, but everyone seems to have, or is, using the CPAP. As I said before I'm unable to use the CPAP. Has anyone had to resort to surgery andthe same, or similar life changing experiences? If so, please answer. Thanks so much, Jeannie
Melinda Hertel Comment by Melinda Hertel on April 20, 2009 at 7:10pm
I have to say that my experience has been more like Patrick's. Once I started CPAP and felt better, I tried stopping my antidepressant. Unfortunately, I had to go back on it. I think that physicians, especially psychiatrists, would do better to look into the possible causes for the depression instead of just prescribing drugs. Although I have to stay on the antidepressant, it would have been nice to be evaluated for sleep apnea too, since the CPAP has helped me sleep, which in turn helps the depression. Also, physicians need to consider sleep apnea for every patient who complains of chronic fatigue and depression. I don't fit the profile for sleep apnea--I'm not obese, my neck is thin, I am a female, etc. The only reason I was tested for sleep apnea is because I worked for a sleep specialist. And even then it took five years of working for him before I was tested and diagnosed!
Banyon Comment by Banyon on March 18, 2009 at 1:04pm
Sally,

You sound a little bit like me. When I was diagnosed with sleep apnea, I was thrilled!

I was thrilled because I knew there was a treatment that could give me my life back.

Good luck,
Sally Comment by Sally on March 18, 2009 at 12:22pm
I'm so glad I found this site, I'm newly diagnosed and dont have a machine yet but am looking forward to it. I've had 2 sleep studies, one without CPAP and last nite, one with. Both times I was very uncomfortable and didnt sleep well but I'm anxious to get set up at home. I too have all the problems described by so many here, depression, tiredness etc etc. I'm SO praying that this will help, I'm 62 and would like to really enjoy the rest of my life.

CPAP Supplies



Latest Activity

Yup, if you've got insurance, your insurance dictates which local DME providers you can use. Just because you bought your CPAP elsewhere does NOT mean that your insurance contracted providers can't or won't provide your masks and other accessories.…
43 minutes ago
Linda, thanks your your help. When I call Apria, I wil ask them why they did not offer me a payment plan. Good luck!
1 hour ago
Hi Candace, Apria is giving me a payment plan for 10 months, after that I will buy it if I still need it. In the mean time, all of the folks here are so helpful they told me the best cpap to get and low and behold, Apria did not give me a newer mode…
1 hour ago
Linda, I read your question re: CPAP Machine and Apria. I also am not impressed with them. I have Kaiser and Kaiser will not pay for my equipment. Apria says that I have to pay all costs up front. Are you on a payment plan with Apria. I have severe…
1 hour ago
candace wells, Jon and CLIFTON MCDONALD joined SleepGuide
1 hour ago
First, let me say, Thank you for going to bat for us. I think you are doing a fantastic job in spreading OSA awareness and providing us with OSA a place to go for support. Apparently there is no connection between a college degree and intelligence,…
3 hours ago
You hit the nail on the head. I had a similar experience last year with another organization, The Alzheimer's Association. I ask for permission to pass out a flyer, "Does Sleep Apnea Cause Alzheimer's Disease?," at one of their annual meetings regar…
4 hours ago
Then she should say that... Say anything other than the falsehood that the connection between OSA and heart disease isn't sufficiently proven. 
4 hours ago
"Respironics recommends that new patients purchase their devices, masks and initial accessories from a homecare company that can provide an individualized patient equipment set-up, clinical and after-sale support, and a program to assist patients wi…
4 hours ago
Maybe you should be the communications director for the AHA ;-).
4 hours ago
I believe that individuals should be free to make decisions for themselves. This goes for the patients and the providers. The patient is free to decide what to do and who to pay for what services. The provider is free to decide what services he offe…
4 hours ago
I'M NOT A 100% SURE OF THE NAME OF MY MASK I THINK IT'S CALLED A PROFILE LITE IT HAS A THICK GEL CUSHION ON THE FORHEAD PIECE AND THE ALL AROUND THE MASK. I STILL END UP WITH RED MARKS ON THE BRIDGE OF MY NOSE AND FOREHEAD BUT THEY FADE IN AN HOUR O…
5 hours ago
by no means am i suggesting that this one person believes one thing or another. rather, she is the director of marketing and communications for the AHA. it is her job to communicate the organization's viewpoints to the public, and that's what she wa…
5 hours ago
HEY, I read the funny e-mails! HAH, I'm heading north tomorrow...
5 hours ago
Jon added a discussion
I received my machine in March with a nasal pillow mask. I switched to a full face mask because I was breathing thru my mouth.I was struggling with getting used to wearing the mask, finally got to the point of wearing it every night.I could not get…
6 hours ago
Ah ha, BirdShell!!! You can ignore me, but we managed to lure you out of your hiding place w/this thread, eh?? Too bad too. Danielle, Ashley, Nicole and I are all meeting at La Placita in Saginaw for lunch tomorrow. I'll be thinking of you!!!! Nico…
6 hours ago
I agree with your advice,Mike.Once I was treated for a sinus infection,I had replaced everything .Also, it is a good idea to use saline to cleanse the sinuses at least twice daily . You may look into the use of a Nettie Pot,,,,that can throughly cle…
6 hours ago
I tried wearing a band aid on the bridge of my nose the other night and it helped, but not enough. Most of the "solutions' that I've found end up causing to much air to leak. I started wearing the bandana (folded in several layers and tied like a he…
6 hours ago
I have to comment! I ran Jump Rope for Heart (JRFH) activities/fundraisers in my classes for years. (For more information: http://www.aahperd.org/jump/ and http://www.americanheart.org/presenter.jhtml?identifier=2360 This is a good condensation of t…
6 hours ago
I've beeb using Sleep Strip for years. It's a good screening test that correlates pretty well with formal sleep studies. It won't give you a number, but rather ranges from none, to mild, moderate or severe. You still need a doctor's prescription. Ty…
6 hours ago

© 2010   Created by The SleepGuide Crew.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service