SleepGuide

Sleep Apnea Forum Bringing Power to the People

Mike

The CPAP Customer --- It's Not Who You Think

Quick: who is the CPAP customer? The one who spends each night hooked up to a hose and a machine to manage a serious health condition, right? Wrong. Or at least that is what the CEO of Philips Respironics would have us believe. In an email sent to clinicians and other industry insiders, the CEO, Donald Spence, comforted DMEs and clinicians worried that a new web-based data monitoring tool, Encore Anywhere, would work an end-run around their control of patient data, and be available, to, heaven forbid.... patients, the very people whose health and well being actually depend on it! Not to fear, Mr./Ms. DME -- Mr. Spence writes that "while it's true that Philips offers consumer products, our core products in sleep and home respiratory are prescribed medical devices that require specialized care to help ensure effective therapy and compliance."

We at SleepGuide are staunch advocates of patients' right to access their CPAP data. We believe that the product titans like Respironics and ResMed do patients a disservice when they suppress our access to data about our therapy. Furthermore, and just as important from a business perspective, we believe they ultimately harm themselves, DMEs, sleep labs, clinicians and sleep physicians when they suppress patient access to this data. The reason is that the data shows patients in a very direct, meaningful way the upside to wearing a cumbersome device to bed every night. Also, if something is wrong, a patient can work with clinicians to switch things up, and make the therapy more effective and comfortable. For an industry that sees roughly half of its potential revenue evaporate due to non-compliance, giving access to data isn't only the right thing to do. It's the lucrative thing to do.

If Respironics or others would like to defend the current Respironics position, we would like to hear from them about why it's defensible.

Tags: apnea, cpap, dme, encore, philips, respironics, sleep, software

Comment

You need to be a member of SleepGuide to add comments!

Join SleepGuide

Judy Comment by Judy on March 21, 2009 at 1:51pm
Unfortunately, the FDA (in the US) dictates who Respironics and the other manufacturers' "customers" are - and you are right, it isn't the end users, the patients. You are placing the blame on the wrong shoulders. Blame the medical profession, blame our idiots in Washington, blame the FDA but don't waste your time and energy blaming the manufacturers.

Resmed developed and provided the advanced patient menu for their xPAPs, Respironics produces the patient version of their software, EncoreViewer. Puritan Bennett (now Covidien) has made their software, Silverlining (and recently, Sandman) available at a reasonable cost to their users for quite some time. The laws in the USA are VERY DIFFERENT from other countries regarding our xPAPs. So take your beef up w/the FDA and your government legislators, the true guilty culprits.
sleepycarol Comment by sleepycarol on February 8, 2009 at 7:02am
I think the key is getting ALL cpap users DATA-CAPABLE machines. Claire, if I read your profile correctly you have a Resmed 7 Lightweight. It is an entry level machine and doesn't provide any detailed data but compliance, meaning the number of days and hours you have used your machine. So even if the data was available via the web for download, your machine's information wouldn't provide any useful information on your treatment.

I feel all users should be given data capable machines that provide more than just compliance numbers. As far as being able to access the information from the web, I am unsure how that will drive the economics of the cost of the machines since those machines will cost more to produce, although Resmed does have the technology to do this on some of their machines, but I am unfamiliar with their machines. At the present time, data capable machines are available that provide detail data, via the data that is downloaded into the computer by a card reader and software -- I would think that the blind and visually impaired would have access to this same information as long as they purchased the card reader and software just like the rest of us. In my opinion, the blind and visually impaired have the same options that us sighted users have at the present time.
Claire A. Murray Comment by Claire A. Murray on February 8, 2009 at 5:55am
My comment is directed at the statement that some machines permit the user to view data directly on the machine, thus web downloadable data isn't necessary. THIS IS Oh So Wrong! The visually impaired or blind user of a device CANNOT view the data on the machine but CAN download and view the data from the web.

Thus, it is imperative that all users be given equal access to the data and that means providing it in a manner that is viewable by ALL users.

enough said?
Daniel Comment by Daniel on January 21, 2009 at 12:24pm
I have several points to make:
- Numeric reports for diabetics have real meaning and patients can easily be taught how to interpret those numbers. AHI and Leak statistics are attempts to quantify fuzzier concepts and in my opinion require greater expertise and experience than most providers are willing to share with patients.

- I became a DME provider specifically for sleep apnea because I too am a hosehead. When I got my first CPAP, I had a totally different career - one that placed a very high value on good customer service. The provider (it has five letters in the name...) basically handed me a machine and a mask and said good luck. I struggled for more than three months before I found out that alternative masks even existed. With the dot com implosion of 2001, I had to change careers, and I settled on sleep disorders because I knew there had to be a better way to do things.

- I am proud to say that if you live in the San Francisco area and call ResMed's 800 number asking for a knowledgeable provider of their equipment, you will be directed to my company, SomniHealth. I personally believe their ResScan software is a little tougher to interpret and use than Respironics, but it has just as much, if not more good information in there. I work with one sleep lab that insists that I dispense Respironics equipment because their doctors like seeing only one type of report. I don't argue with them because at least the doctors are reading the reports, and asking for regular updates from me, which I applaud.

- Three cheers to Angela D's comments. Right on target!
Angela D. Comment by Angela D. on January 21, 2009 at 8:17am
I have been in the sleep profession for over a decade and it's all too clear that the lack of "upfront" patient education and care is one of the biggest obstacles in providing long term quality care. Too many patients do not know enough about their diagnosis or their equipment. The downloads are very helpful indeed, as well as patient feedback, but all equipment is not created equally. The different manufacturers use different technology to count, register, flag, track and treat apnea events.
The sleep professionals sending the prescriptions into these DME providers, should track and verify that the patients are educated and that the service from the DME was of high standards. Someone has to hold the DME responsible for having properly trained RTs and great up front education and patient care. If the service or training is poor, the MD needs to stop sending that company prescriptions until the problem is resolved and they have proved worthy of performing PAP set ups. Get them where it hurts($$$), so to speak...
Patients need to complain to the Dr. that prescribed the CPAP. The staff will take role of liason between DME & pt. It is also easier for the MDs to make sure that the regional sales reps. from the manufacturers, have properly trained the DMEs on the types of equipment that they want to prescribe. Eventually the good DMEs will rise above the bad DMEs and hopefully we can save future CPAP users from the frustration and lack of knowledge so many others have faced in the past. (if the Dr. don't want to listen, staff won't help???, you need to change doctors!!)
Dave D. Comment by Dave D. on January 21, 2009 at 7:07am
As with anything, for patients that can make use of this data and want it, it should be available to them. One must keep in mind that the simple act of being involved in this discussion on this website sets us apart from the masses that use (or are supposed to use) PAP and do not have a clue. Not that we are any smarter or capable, but that we are interested and concerned about or health. The vast majority do not have that insight.
Judy Comment by Judy on January 20, 2009 at 8:49pm
Daniel Levy,

I realize I've come down pretty heavy on your profession and I certainly didn't mean to sound like I was aiming my comments at you personally. I've had the misfortune to first encounter a less than desirable or helpful and less than truthful DME RT and then a heck of a nice DME RT who doesn't know the Resmeds or even want to know or try to explain the data from the ResScan software.

I would DEARLY love to have a DME RT such as yourself who IS willing to interpret the data downloads rather than have to struggle thru trying to interpret the data for myself!! I certainly wish you were in my neck of the woods and took my insurance! I'd be knocking at your door, except I get the impression that you most likely don't have the ResScan software and the experience w/the Resmed devices either??? *sigh*
Judy Comment by Judy on January 20, 2009 at 7:13pm
Oh *sigh*

"the data report doesn't include any interpretation. Without being thoroughly trained in what the data means, it can easily be misunderstood."

And apnea patients are not as intelligent and capable as diabetics. We are a dumb and ignorant lot. HORSEPUCKIES! Yoo hoo! "Apneans" are every bit as capable of being educated as the diabetics!!!

"That is supposed to be the responsibility of the DME provider." Yep, it sure is and it is unfortunate that too many fail miserably in that respect. Not to say that there aren't good local DME providers out there - but there sure aren't enough of them. The CPAP failure rate is PROOF of that!

CPAP therapy is left to the WRONG HANDS. DME providers aren't expected to educate and train the diabetics on monitoring and adjusting their therapy are they? Who DOES educate and train the diabetics in monitoring and adjusting their therapy? Where is that equivalent for the CPAP therapy patient?
sleepycarol Comment by sleepycarol on January 20, 2009 at 12:07pm
In my opinion it IS about the patient taking responsibility for their treatment!! Patients should be educated about their treatment -- after all who has the most at stake in their therapy -- certainly not the DME.

My DME (and those in my rural area) do NOT know squat about cpap equipment nor do they care.

When I picked up my first machine the RT (a trained registered respiratory therapist) gave me an M series PLUS machine and had the nerve to argue with me that it provides useful data including events that happen during the night. I was also told it was NOT in my best interest to get involved with MY therapy!!! Guess what I changed DME's.

For those wanting to know -- THE PLUS M series only provides compliance data -- nothing useful about that except for the insurance companies and the DME's.

I CAN interpret MY OWN numbers as I am not stupid and have learned through much studying what the numbers mean and why they are important to my health. Yes, I have done the "horrible deed" and changed my own pressure. It was only by tracking my numbers did I realize that my therapy wasn't working for me -- my doctor is fully aware of this change and is okay with it -- she knows I don't do it blind and I have the knowledge and information to do it. She has stated I probably know more about sleep apnea than she does as I have read and read and studied about sleep apnea, the various machines, masks, what the data means, what to do with the data, etc. After it is MY health on the line.
Daniel Comment by Daniel on January 20, 2009 at 10:42am
Sometimes patients forget that it isn't about the numbers - it's all about how you feel when you wake up in the morning, It's about not falling asleep while your driving. The apnea/hypopnea index is an artifical construct that is an attempt to quantify the severity of the disorder. However, some people who have been classified with "mild" sleep apnea (AHI between 5 and 15) present symptoms that are just as devastating (or more so) than people who have "severe" sleep apnea with an AHI of 60 events per hour. The numbers simply don't tell the whole story.

In addition, the data report doesn't include any interpretation. Without being thoroughly trained in what the data means, it can easily be misunderstood. This leads to long customer service calls with Respironics, ResMed, the DME provider, or the doctor. As a DME provider, I am thrilled to talk to my patients about their data, and I rarely charge anything for a data download and interpretation (note that it isn't just for a download - it's for the interpretation). But ResMed and Respironics really don't want to speak to patients directly, nor should they. That is supposed to be the responsibility of the DME provider.

CPAP Supplies

sleep-doctor
Buy Oxygen Pillow for Deeper Sleep Through Deeper Breathing

cpap supplies


Latest Activity

steve Archer and Randal are now friends
18 minutes ago
Same stuff. 3 yr standard warranty on machines.. i think its 2 in US???
18 minutes ago
Hi Michelle , the 406 is a very small mask, your nose is small but where on the bridge of your nose does it rest?? A slightly larger mask like the fisher paykel zest or a medium softgel mask from resmed may work.. i work in canada at a sleep company…
22 minutes ago
For me, this has been the most frustrating physical problem I've ever had, mainly because I can't seem to find a mask that will work for me, without leaving sore marks on my forehead and the bridge of my nose. And then there was the gel one that jus…
33 minutes ago
The Stanford surgeries do dramatically reduce the AHI of some number of patients. They are not "cures" and they are not universally effective; I would also like to see how many are still effective after five years. I have also had an MMA with a few…
36 minutes ago
I wonder if you have TMJ or if you're grinding your teeth while uding your CPAP. I know that they say if you have TMJ, you're more llikely to suffer from sleep Apnea. You should go to your dentist and have it checked out. Maybe you've been grinding…
40 minutes ago
I turn my as high as it will go every night, which is still not nearly high enough in the winter, with gas heat running. I wake up with sandpaper tongue and all, even on max settting. Very frustrating. I think I was overcharged for a really crappy m…
41 minutes ago
I am 65 - as of two days ago! Was diagnosed with sleep apnea last August, but also definely had longer. PS: Thanks, Mike for all you do for this site - ANd many thanks to all who contribute!! This site has been such a BLESSING>
48 minutes ago
My doctor and provider are the unmotivated ones, and uneducated to the extent that I made myself in an afternoon and a half. Personally, I agree with Brad; OSA is a simple, physics problem, and why there isn't more being done to find a surgical solu…
51 minutes ago
amen, this a very painful surgery to recover from as an adult. I had mine removed 2 years ago. It was absolutely no help. My new doctor said I should have not had it done. It only made treating my apnea harder.
1 hour ago
I used to work for the phone company and one night we had a driving rain that had filled some radio waveguides (rectangular copper pipe that connects the radios to the antennas on top of the tower) with water, and the waveguides needed to be dried o…
1 hour ago
99 left a comment for lia deneau
1 hour ago
i put my cpap inside a shoe box with an open jar of vick near the rear filter and turn on my machine and put the lid on the shoe box
1 hour ago
Good Luck! Enjoy Ann Arbor! UoM hosiptal is amazing
2 hours ago
No. Never. The results of the sleep test were sent to a capital city 300 km away. The technition did say that I was a very disturbed sleeper.
2 hours ago
When I first started using Pur-sleep Aromatherapy I wanted a clean pad. The ones supplied at the time were reusable and I am too lazy to wash them daily. Others suggested to keep reusing them. Bret has since came up with a "disposable" pad that can…
3 hours ago
Carol, that was entirely Too Much Information about pantiliners. :) I cannot unread and I cannot unsee the mental picture of pantiliners .
3 hours ago
a a , I've woken up with swollen eyes and a somehat sore jaw. The soreness in my jaw resolved quickly. But, this was when I was wearing a FFM. A few months late, but welcome to SleepGuide. Mary Z. A Navy Vet and proud of it.
3 hours ago
4 hours ago
4 hours ago

© 2010   Created by The SleepGuide Crew

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service